Much like Gatsby and Daisy, he chooses empty illusions, attempts to recover an irretrievable past, and disregards moral concerns in favor of his personal well-being. Simply stated, because Nick believes that Daisy—like other women—has limited options, he does not hold her accountable for her actions. Even more precisely, because he believes that she lacks the free will and the ability to be self-reliant which are necessary prerequisites for independent moral choice, he is able to accept her lack of integrity as an understandable and even appropriate strategy for achieving her goals.
In contrast, his need to believe that he and Gatsby have integrity and the ability to make moral choices leads him to several conflicting conclusions about the degree to which each was responsible for his choices. Significantly, he portrays Daisy as sharing both his notion of female powerlessness and his acceptance of deception as an appropriate way of dealing with that powerlessness. In contrast to Gatsby who saw marriage to Daisy as being the material manifestation of his having achieved success, Daisy subscribes to the version of the dream that applies to women, that marriage to a successful man is not the symbol of success but success itself.
Indeed, Daisy never questions the concept that her only choices are among suitors. Even her single attempt to defy convention, her plan to join Gatsby in New York before he went overseas with the army, is in keeping with her belief that her happiness depended on her having a relationship with a successful man.
She is unaware that Gatsby has deceived her about his financial status. She wanted her life shaped now, immediately—and the decision must be made by some force of love, of money, of unquestionable practicality—that was close at hand. That force took shape in the middle of spring with the arrival of Tom Buchanan. There was a wholesome bulkiness about his person and his position and Daisy was flattered. Doubtless there was a certain struggle and a certain relief. Both Daisy and Nick fail to acknowledge fully the toll that playing the part of an unthinking dependent woman has taken on Daisy.
Playing the role of a beautiful little fool did not bring her happiness any more than it gave her life shape or purpose. Tom had frequently been unfaithful to her, the first time within three months of their marriage.
Perhaps most tragically, Daisy contributes to the perpetuation of the mythology which has denied her her own humanity. She treats her daughter as a beautiful object, bringing her out only for show and then apparently forgetting her. Her language in addressing the child is telling. She does not call her by name only the governess does. You absolute little dream.
His abundance of expensive shirts, a sign of the beauty that material success can bring, moves Daisy to a moment of what appears to be genuine emotion. But in the end Daisy turns to Tom again because, like Nick, she expects that men will have integrity, at least outside the sexual realm. It should be noted that Gatsby similarly denies Daisy her full humanity.
His insistence that she declare that she had never loved Tom, born out of his need to restore Daisy to her younger self, points to his inability to perceive Daisy as a person who has grown and changed. By so simplifying the moral complexities of this situation, Nick avoids having to take responsibility for his own actions. He had thought that Gatsby would use cardboard imitations of book covers. He admires Gatsby for going to such great lengths to project an image.
Tom realises that it was Gatsby's car that struck and killed Myrtle. Back at Daisy and Tom's home, Gatsby tells Nick that Daisy was driving the car that killed Myrtle but he will take the blame. We learn from Nick about Gatsby's true origins. His real name is James Gatz. He comes from North Dakota.
At the age of 17 he changed his name to Jay Gatsby after meeting a rich mining prospector called Dan Cody. The book is, among other things, a coming of age story for Nick Carraway. The most commonly discussed weaknesses of his character relate to his judgemental nature. Nick introduces himself as someone who refrains from judging others, yet as a narrator judgement is a rather constant habit for Carraway.
In the story, after Nick leaves New York it is revealed that he has a host of problems that we did not see in his earlier years. This includes Alcoholism, Fits of Rage, and Depression. In many ways, Nick is an unreliable narrator : he's dishonest about his own shortcomings downplaying his affairs with other women, as well as his alcohol use , and he doesn't tell us everything he knows about the characters upfront for example, he waits until Chapter 6 to tell us the truth about Gatsby's origins, even In both book and movie, Gatsby is waiting for a phone call from Daisy, but in the film, Nick calls, and Gatsby gets out of the pool when he hears the phone ring.
He's then shot, and he dies believing that Daisy was going to ditch Tom and go way with him. The Great Gatsby can be considered a tragedy in that it revolves around a larger-than-life hero whose pursuit of an impossible goal blinds him to reality and leads to his violent death.
Gatsby's tragic flaw is his inability to wake up from his dream of the past and accept reality. Does nick admire gatsby? Asked by: Liam Bednar. Is Gatsby real? How did Nick and Gatsby meet? However, Daisy is already married and has a family with Tom Buchanan—a famous polo player.
The novel is simply a love story; it is a story of a hopeless romantic in love with a woman whom he will never have again. With the lack of morality and unrestrained materialism of the people around him, Nick had witnessed the gift of hope of Jay Gatsby and the evils within New York City. The whole story is narrated by Nick Carraway, who had close experiences with both Gatsby and Daisy. Looking at the way Nick narrated the story, it can be ascertained that Nick Carraway is biased to Gatsby throughout the story, in such a way that the accounts are very much one-sided as opposed to it being an impartial reminiscence of his past.
Nick says that he is a man who is inclined to reserve all judgments 7 , when in fact throughout the story he has been making negative judgments towards the other characters except Gatsby. He called the other characters a rotten crowd and that Gatsby is worth a whole lot put together He describes Jordan Baker as an incurably dishonest 64 and careless person 65 , Tom and Daisy as careless people who smash-up things and creatures and then retreat back into their money or vast carelessness , Mr.
McKee as feminine 36 , and George Wilson as a spiritless man Nick admits that the only one exempted to his reactions is Gatsby, and that he represents everything for which he has an unaffected scorn 8 —making it difficult for him to make judgments against him. Unlike the other characters in the story, Nick shows approval of Gatsby by the way he describes him and his actions.
Nick has always been a good friend to Gatsby. He supported and helped Gatsby in getting Daisy back even if he knows that what Gatsby is doing is wrong. Nick even agreed to the favor of Gatsby into hosting a tea party with only Gatsby and Daisy as his invited guests He made sure that Tom Buchanan will not be around at the tea party.
0コメント